Way too overpowered bonuses. The end result is that only
the guildmaster would be good enough to take on certain
mobs (i.e. effectively limit that only one and the same
people can do certain items) or alternatively mobs would
become ridiculously easy.
For some reason I figured Glaurung's sarcasm was obvious. However, two arches
failed to see it, maybe this shows the contrast between active players view
and wiz/arch view on balance.